All the votes are in for the “Make Bugzilla Pretty” contest, and we have a winner!
First off, let me say that every single entry was amazing. Every single person who entered had innovative ideas, and nearly every entry was prettier than our current UI.
There were four candidates who were mentioned in some positive way by almost every voter:
Any of these designers would be a worthwhile addition to any UX team anywhere. Simply the ability to take Bugzilla’s existing UI and turn it into something that nearly everybody finds attractive is an accomplishment that few designers could achieve. In the 13 years of Bugzilla’s history, I’ve never seen it done before these entries. I would be personally happy to write a recommendation for any of the above designers, and they may contact me for that if they wish.
Let’s just say a few words about each of these designs:
There were a ton of positive comments on the usability aspects and organization of Alex Faaborg’s [Bracket] theme, particularly some of the new fields suggested and the brilliant use of color to improve the scanability of the page. It was impressive that everything on the page is basically text or lines, and yet it creates a very readable, clean, simple layout.
We expect future versions of Bugzilla to draw a lot on the usability concepts present in Faaborg’s design, even though it is not the first-place winner.
There were a lot of positive comments on the use of space in Zeeshan Syed’s design. The color contrast really makes things readable, the tab navigation is very clear, and the section titles really stand out.
Voters were almost overwhelmingly positive about Long Duong’s design. Many people mentioned that they liked the clean lines and very “Bugzilla” feel of the bug page, and that the collapsible sections were a great touch while still being visually appealing. There was also a lot of positive feedback about the header design–people really loved its organization and style. Finally, the home page design was just really cool.
Based on the number of votes and the general amount of positive feedback, Duong is our first runner-up for the Make Bugzilla Pretty contest, and it is very likely that we will end up incorporating some of his UI concepts into our final design.
This was a stiff competition, and all of the above designs would have worked great as our new UI. However, the winner of the “Make Bugzilla Pretty” contest, and indeed the recipient of the majority of votes, is Jonathan Wilde:
Jonathan’s ability to convert our UI into something beautiful and simple that even new users will find approachable is beyond anything that we had ever imagined could be done with Bugzilla. We are thrilled that Jonathan has won, and excited to implement his design as the official UI of Bugzilla 5.0.
Thanks to Everybody
We would like to thank everybody who entered. Your entries made this contest a fascinating and transformative experience for the Bugzilla Project. We were consistently amazed at the creativity, intelligence, and design sense that so many of you displayed, and wish you great fortune in the future of your careers.
27 thoughts on “Winner of the “Make Bugzilla Pretty” Contest”
As you say, they’ve all got something.
Mr. Wilde’s design is outstanding, but the garden of gray (?) help buttons is a distraction. Maybe these could be lighter (but not disabled) and only fade in when the associated field has focus.
Almost the same white on gray is used for the Description, Comment 1, Comment 2 badges, but I think those are just decorative.
That is exactly what he designed it to do, in fact! 🙂 See the full design with notes here:
No more ASCII art? 😦
Ha! Well, there will probably be an option for that. 🙂 I have some ideas on how to implement the new comment stuff.
Official theme in Bugzilla 5.0…I don’t think I can wait that long 😉
Any chance we can try this out sooner in the dev builds?
Well, it doesn’t exist in the “HTML and CSS” sense yet, it’s only an image. It has to be implemented, and hasn’t yet. There will be a branch where this code exists, though, once we start coding it, so you can try it then.
Alex’s work is just awesome, as always. This guy is impressive.
Seriously, Alex is an incredible designer and HCI engineer, one of the best of the best.
My favorite theme is a Alex Faaborg’s one (proposed HTML e-mail design is very attractive). Hope this will be available some day… Concerning winning theme – putting a Status field on a bottom of a page is a misunderstanding. IMHO it is crucial field and should be put very close to bug number.
Anyway, I can’t wait to see new UI live!!!
The status is also at the top – see “Confirmed” in green just under the bug title
I like any Design from Long Duong, great!!
hi, a silly question….where can i actually download those skins?
I wanna knows that too!!
When is this going to be ready????
Please please please release this sooner than 5.0!! We want it!!
So where can we download those themes?
I think these are only designs right now and going to be coded. Max any idea of a timeline?
Yes, would be completely looking forward to Bugzilla 5.0 with this theme. We just installed Bugzilla 4.4.1 (latest stable version as I am writing this) and I realized that the new theme hasn’t yet been included albeit this post being more than 2 years old. 🙂 Would love an update.
I would also really like to get my hands on these themes for Bugzilla 5!
Whatever happened to this? It looks like this was abandoned. 5.0 is here and it is still ugly.
Its april 2016 and still nothing.
Regretfully they said in their own bugzilla it wouldnt be implemented.
What’s being implemented will be loosely based on it, but the architecture changed so much by the time people got working on it that it didn’t quite fit as-is and we had to change it around a bit. We’ll hopefully have the new UI in Bugzilla 6.